Have you ever come across a promising stretch of trout water, only to discover that you couldn’t fish it because it was on private property?
Maybe you spotted a beautiful run from the road or followed a river upstream until you encountered posted signs. Did you ask the landowner for permission or turn around and look for somewhere else to fish?
John Harrington, a Pennsylvania angler and founder of Hooksetr, believes he has a solution.
His concept is straightforward: connect anglers with private landowners who are willing to provide access to their water through a reservation system. Some properties are available at no cost, while others require anglers to pay a fee.
But the idea has generated considerable skepticism. Critics worry that creating a marketplace for fishing access could encourage landowners who currently allow free fishing to begin charging for it. Could a business intended to open more water ultimately make less of it freely accessible?
I recently spent time with Harrington and interviewed him about Hooksetr, the problem he’s trying to solve, and the potential impact of turning private fishing access into a marketplace.

Will Hooksetr Encourage Landowners to Post Water That Is Currently Open to Fishing?
This was the first concern I raised with Harrington. If landowners see an opportunity to make money by charging anglers for access, what prevents them from posting water that has traditionally been open to the public?
Addressing an Existing Problem
“The entire inspiration behind the company was based on the amount of posting and privatization that already exists in the state,” Harrington explained. He described his intention as providing “a solution to an existing problem, not the creation of a problem that doesn’t exist.”
Harrington believes Hooksetr can help reverse that trend by approaching landowners who currently prohibit fishing and giving them reasons to reconsider. He explained that some landowners are reluctant to grant permission because they don’t want to manage the responsibilities that come with allowing strangers onto their property.
His service is designed to address those concerns by verifying anglers, coordinating reservations, establishing parking arrangements, and communicating property-specific rules. For some landowners, financial compensation may provide an additional incentive to open their water.
“The goal is to open up water that’s off limits, not to increase the amount of places in the state where you can’t fish.”
Protecting Existing Free Access
But what happens if a landowner who currently allows free fishing decides to post the property and begin charging through Hooksetr?
I asked Harrington directly whether he would accept that landowner onto his platform.
“I would tell them no,” he said, adding that they would be welcome to list on the app without charging for access.
He believes landowners who already provide free access should be recognized and encouraged to continue.
Harrington says Hooksetr will not facilitate converting existing free fishing access into paid access.
Is Hooksetr Actually Creating More Fishing Access?
Harrington’s stated mission is to open water that anglers currently cannot fish. But what evidence does he have that Hooksetr is accomplishing that goal?
Turning No into Yes
Harrington spent much of 2026 traveling across Pennsylvania, meeting face-to-face with landowners whose properties include streams that are currently inaccessible to anglers.
“I’ve met with them, and I’ve converted a number of the noes into yeses,” he said.
He believes the personal relationships he’s building are essential to the company’s success.
“The more face-to-face engagement I have, the more interaction and relationship building that I do, the more receptive the landowner community is becoming to the idea of listing.”
He also acknowledged that some landowners simply prefer to keep their properties closed. For others, the opportunity to receive compensation can make the difference.

Why Not Just Ask Permission?
Anglers have traditionally gained access to private water by asking landowners directly. I asked Harrington why that approach isn’t sufficient.
Harrington doesn’t discourage anglers from approaching landowners directly. In fact, he believes they should keep seeking permission. He sees Hooksetr as another option when those conversations haven’t resulted in access.
His answer focused on the responsibilities landowners assume when they allow people onto their property.
According to Harrington, Hooksetr verifies fishing licenses, manages reservations, coordinates arrival times, and provides anglers with property-specific instructions covering parking, access points, fishing boundaries, and rules.
“Landowners don’t want to go through the trouble of asking people for that type of information, but it’s important for them to know who’s there and when they’re going to be there.”
Harrington also believes that irresponsible behavior by some anglers has damaged relationships between landowners and the fishing community. He described properties that had been closed to fishing for years following negative experiences with visitors.
Harrington believes that an organized system with clear expectations and someone responsible for coordinating access may convince reluctant landowners to reconsider allowing fishing.

Can Anglers Fish Through Private Property in Pennsylvania?
In Pennsylvania, private property ownership along a stream doesn’t always mean the public has no legal right to fish it. On certain waterways, anglers may have the right to fish through privately owned stretches when entering from a legal public access point.
I asked Harrington whether Hooksetr includes any water that anglers already have the legal right to fish.
He explained that his listings involve properties where landowner permission is required, rather than stretches anglers can already legally access and fish.
“You would need that landowner to say yes, you can come fish here.”
Hooksetr’s stated purpose is to provide access where permission is necessary, not to charge anglers for fishing rights they already possess.
The Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission explains that anglers generally have the right to fish legally navigable waterways, even where those waters pass through private property. However, that right does not give anglers permission to cross private land to reach the water.
Could Paid Fishing Access Put Some Water Beyond the Reach of Anglers?
Even if Hooksetr succeeds in opening previously inaccessible water, another question remains: Who will be able to afford it?
What Will Anglers Pay?
I asked Harrington how he determines what anglers should pay to fish a property and whether he worries that paid access could put some opportunities beyond the reach of everyday anglers.
Harrington explained that he surveyed anglers at The Fly Fishing Show in Lancaster, PA, last year to better understand what they would consider reasonable for a half- or full-day private-water access.
Responses ranged from as little as $5 or $10 to several hundred dollars for a full day.
Harrington uses that feedback to help landowners understand what anglers might be willing to pay for access. However, the final decision about whether to charge and how much belongs to the landowner.
“They have the ultimate say in what they charge if they decide to charge at all,” Harrington explained.
He also emphasized that some properties are available at no cost.
“In cases where landowners don’t feel the need to charge, I’m listing those on the site for free.”
Could Paid Access Become the New Normal?
I also asked Harrington whether a successful marketplace for private fishing access might encourage other landowners to begin charging anglers, even if they never list their properties on Hooksetr.
“My personal belief is that that incentive exists with or without my service,” he responded.
Harrington pointed to the private fishing clubs and paid-access opportunities that already exist. He pointed out that landowners don’t need Hooksetr to recognize the financial value of their property.
How Does Hooksetr Make Money?
Harrington’s vision depends on convincing landowners to open their properties and finding anglers willing to reserve them. But how does the business make money, and what evidence shows the concept is gaining traction?
Hooksetr business model
Harrington explained that landowners who joined his early “stream team” receive 90% of the reservation revenue, while Hooksetr retains 10%. He intends to honor that arrangement for those early participants, although the company’s share may increase for future listings.
Hooksetr is structured as a public benefit company, reflecting Harrington’s intention to build a business around responsible fishing access and conservation. He believes the platform can encourage better relationships between anglers and landowners while giving property owners greater control over how their water is used.
Not every property generates revenue. Some landowners choose to provide free access, which Harrington says is an important part of the company’s mission.
For now, Harrington is funding the business himself. He acknowledged that Hooksetr is operating at a loss and that he has not established exactly how many properties or reservations it will take to become profitable.
What Has Hooksetr Accomplished So Far?
At the time of our interview, Harrington reported 17 properties listed on Hooksetr, including three offering free access, with a fourth free listing in development. He also said more than 100 anglers had registered on the platform.
Harrington spent much of 2026 meeting with landowners and developing listings before actively promoting the service to anglers in the fall.
He says those efforts have persuaded some landowners who previously refused fishing access to reconsider. However, not every listing represents newly accessible water. Some properties already permitted fishing for a fee, and Hooksetr provides a more organized way for anglers to arrange access.
According to Harrington, 11 of Hooksetr’s 17 listings represent fishing opportunities that were previously unavailable to anglers. Some of the other listings provide a more organized way to arrange access to water where fishing was already permitted.
Following a brief advertising campaign in the fall, Harrington reported more than a dozen booking requests and five completed fishing trips through Hooksetr. He said anglers who used the service provided positive feedback about their experiences, including the quality of the fishing and the ease of arranging access.
Looking ahead to 2027, Harrington hopes to expand Hooksetr’s network of participating landowners across Pennsylvania, particularly in areas where anglers have expressed interest. His longer-term goal is to eventually offer three to five listings in each county.
How Does Hooksetr Address Conservation and Fishing Pressure?
Opening additional water to anglers raises another question: What safeguards are in place to protect the fishery?
Harrington said the landowners he has worked with have emphasized fly fishing only and catch-and-release.
He also explained that Hooksetr reserves each property for a single booking on a given day.
“We also don’t double book.”
Some properties close during hunting season, and Harrington says he is prepared to restrict access when conservation concerns arise.
“If we need to, we’ll close down and make water inaccessible when we feel the need to protect the resource.”
He has also encouraged anglers to recognize and avoid spawning redds and participate in conservation activities, including a Trout Unlimited redd count.
Protecting spawning trout is an issue I’ve explored in more detail in my article, Should Anglers Stay Home During the Spawn?
Harrington believes opening additional private water could distribute fishing pressure across more streams, potentially reducing pressure on heavily used public stretches.
How Does Harrington Respond to Anglers Who Oppose Hooksetr?
Harrington has received considerable criticism since introducing Hooksetr, particularly from anglers concerned about the commercialization of fishing access.
I asked him directly whether any of that criticism was fair.
“I think that the fear and the apprehension about having this exist is reasonable, given what other entities with different interests have done.”
He understands that anglers have watched valuable fishing opportunities become restricted or inaccessible. He believes Hooksetr deserves a chance to show a different outcome, but he also said he wants anglers to hold him accountable.
“I want to continue to keep the communication lines open with the angling community, and I want to be held accountable to do this as best as I possibly can.”

Where Hooksetr Raises Questions
After spending time with John Harrington and discussing Hooksetr at length, one thing became clear to me: I believe he genuinely wants to solve a problem.
Harrington has given considerable thought to the challenges surrounding fishing access. He’s invested his own time and money, traveled across Pennsylvania meeting with landowners, and developed a system intended to address many of the reasons property owners are reluctant to allow anglers onto their land.
I didn’t leave our conversation believing he was an opportunist looking to exploit landowners or profit at the expense of a public resource. Quite the opposite. I found him thoughtful, sincere, and genuinely committed to creating more fishing opportunities.
But believing in someone’s intentions doesn’t mean agreeing with every conclusion they’ve reached. And even a well-intentioned business can have consequences its founder never anticipated.
There are several areas where I think Harrington’s arguments deserve closer examination.
Could Hooksetr Encourage More Posted Water?
This remains my biggest concern.
Harrington argues that the financial incentive to charge for fishing access already exists. He’s right. Private fishing clubs and paid access arrangements are nothing new.
But a marketplace could make that opportunity more visible. Landowners who never considered charging anglers might begin looking at their properties differently when they see others generating income from fishing access.
After our conversation, I found myself reflecting on another aspect of Harrington’s approach.
Consider two landowners along the same stream. One has generously allowed anglers to fish his property for decades without charging a dime. The other has historically refused access but agrees to open his water through Hooksetr in exchange for compensation.
Under Harrington’s policy, the second landowner can earn money from fishing access through Hooksetr, while the first could list his property on the platform only if he continued providing free access.
I understand Harrington’s reasoning. His goal is to create new fishing opportunities without taking away access anglers already enjoy. It’s a policy I respect, and I believe he intends to honor that commitment.
But I wonder what message that sends to landowners who have welcomed anglers onto their properties for years. Could seeing their neighbors earn money eventually cause them to reconsider their own generosity?
Harrington cannot control what those landowners decide to do independently. A landowner who has traditionally allowed free fishing could decide to post the property.
I don’t know whether that would happen, but it’s worth considering. A business designed to open more water could unintentionally influence how landowners think about access they’ve historically provided for free.
How Do We Know Access Is Actually New?
Harrington says he won’t help landowners begin charging for water that is currently available to anglers for free. However, he would consider listing water that was historically open to fishing but has since been closed.
Determining whether a property was previously accessible isn’t always straightforward.
Some landowners allow fishing informally. They might give permission to neighbors, local anglers, or anyone willing to knock on the door and ask.
Harrington explained that he discusses the history of access with landowners. That’s a reasonable starting point, but it may not always tell the complete story.
Harrington reports that 11 of the 17 properties listed on Hooksetr represent previously unavailable fishing opportunities. That’s encouraging, although those figures are based on his assessment of each property’s access history.
Organizing access that already existed can be useful, but it’s different from convincing a landowner to open water that was previously closed.
Can the Business Remain True to Its Mission?
I appreciated Harrington’s openness about the financial realities of Hooksetr. He’s investing his own money, operating at a loss, and trying to build something sustainable.
There’s nothing wrong with wanting to earn a living from a business that provides a useful service.
But Hooksetr earns revenue from paid reservations, not free access. As the company grows, could there be pressure to prioritize paid properties over free opportunities?
I don’t suggest that Harrington would deliberately abandon his principles. I simply recognize that a business’s financial incentives don’t always align perfectly with its stated mission.
Will More Access Benefit Fisheries?
Harrington believes opening private water could reduce fishing pressure on heavily used public streams.
I can see the logic. But I’m not convinced the relationship is that simple.
An angler who pays to fish private water might be replacing a trip to a public stream. Or that angler might simply be adding another day of fishing. Opening previously inaccessible water also introduces fishing pressure to trout populations that may have experienced relatively little angling activity.
Harrington described several safeguards, including limited reservations, catch-and-release requirements, and the possibility of closing properties to protect spawning trout. Those are encouraging measures.
Still, expanding fishing access doesn’t automatically produce a conservation benefit. That will depend on how the water is managed and how anglers use it.
The Bigger Question: The Future of Fishing Access
I genuinely hope Harrington succeeds in what he’s trying to accomplish. If Hooksetr can open water that has long been inaccessible to anglers without contributing to the loss of existing access, that would be a meaningful achievement. I wish him nothing but success in that effort.
But our conversation also raises questions that extend well beyond Hooksetr.
How do we encourage private landowners to allow fishing without creating additional incentives to restrict access? How do we respect property rights while preserving opportunities for anglers who can’t afford to pay for private water? And what responsibility do we have as anglers to maintain the relationships that make access possible in the first place?
I don’t have simple answers, and I suspect Harrington doesn’t either. But I appreciate his willingness to tackle a difficult problem and engage with those who question his approach.
I’m genuinely intrigued by the concept, and I’ll be interested to see how it develops. More importantly, I hope this conversation encourages anglers to think about the future of fishing access and what we can do to protect it.
Join the Conversation
Do you think Hooksetr will eventually provide anglers with more or less access to quality trout fishing in PA?

Thanks for reading, and I hope this article helps you catch a few more trout.
Spend more time on the water.
Jeff Smecker
Founder, TroutStrike Fly Fishing, LLC

©TroutStrike Fly Fishing, LLC


Leave a Reply