Lowest of the Low: My Least Favorite River Conditions

Part # 2 of a 3-Part Series: Go back to Part 1 or Part 3.

I closely monitor a half dozen rivers throughout the year. I think of them as my home waters, even though each one lies two or three hours from my door. They wind through the mountains and valleys of Pennsylvania, slipping past small towns and long stretches of forest, and I track them from a distance. I watch their USGS gauges the way some people watch the stock market. I check the weather in the counties they pass through and imagine how each bend and riffle might look under a shifting sky. However, for months now, the story has remained unchanged. As I wrote in my last post, the rivers I follow are holding at historic lows.

One brief rain event finally broke through in early November. For a moment, it felt like a turning point. The rivers rose. Then they fell again. The levels descended as quickly as they rose. The stones were briefly submerged but were soon re-exposed, and the rivers returned to their fragile shape, unchanged for months.

But I have waited long enough.

These are the moments when living a few hours from every river I care about becomes its own challenge. I am accustomed to long drives now, but distance still dictates how I fish. I do not have the option of fishing for a quick morning session or returning for an evening rise. When I go, I am committed for the entire day. And when a river is this low, that commitment forces me to reset my expectations. A full day in these conditions requires a realistic understanding of what the river has to offer. It asks me to adjust what success looks like before I even step into the water. That is why I have waited during these extreme conditions. But the waiting has gone on long enough. I am going.

At some point in my life, I will live closer to these rivers. For now, I remain at a distance and monitor them as the gauges continue to fall. But distance does not excuse inactivity. The rivers may not return to their normal form before winter arrives, but that does not mean they are empty. The fish are still there. The only thing missing is my willingness to accept the rivers in their current state. So, I have decided to go. I am preparing for an overnight trip and two full days on the water. Or, what’s left of the water.

I know what I am up against.

Choosing the Right River for the Wrong Conditions

The first river I will target is the one I fish the least. It receives more pressure than any other river I frequent. Under normal conditions, I stay away from it because there are too many anglers. I know the access points by heart, and I know how many trucks fill those spaces when the conditions are optimal.

Low water changes everything. It keeps anglers home. Even the dedicated ones hesitate. That hesitation has opened the door for me. If I am going to fish it, this is the moment.

There is another reason. This river receives a welcome infusion of water closer to its mouth, a steady contribution that creates depth and flow even when the rest of the watershed thins out. It also brings in the occasional stocked rainbow trout from the inferior river below. They wander up between seasons and settle in. Technically, they are stocked, but once they take residence here, they act like wild trout. They become part of the river. In these conditions, I will take whatever the river offers. I prefer the wild browns, but if a displaced rainbow wants to play, I will not complain. These are not regular days. I will lean into any opportunity that presents itself.

Adjusting Expectations Before Adjusting Tactics

What makes this trip different is not the gear. It is the mindset. I know the action will not be steady. I know there will be long stretches of silence and still water. I know the riverbed will feel larger than it should, the currents thinner, the fish more cautious.

Low water conditions demand something from the angler. They slow your movements. They sharpen your eyesight. They stretch your patience. They force you to look inward and ask whether you are willing to change the way you fish or whether you will fall back into what is comfortable.

I know I will need to fish from a distance, sometimes much farther than I like. I will need to read faint rises instead of obvious ones. I will need to slow my approach and slow my thinking. I will need to treat every pocket and every piece of structure as a window rather than an invitation.

This is the part of fly fishing that still tests me. Low water is my least preferred condition. There is nowhere to hide. Every false step scatters spooked trout.

Preparing the Setup

This week, I reorganized my gear with this trip in mind. I adjusted my leader and tied a fresh set of lighter flies. I tied a few Dorsey yarn indicators for the first time in a long while, as I knew I might need them.

Here is the plan:

• Small nymphs in sizes 18 through 22
• Tied lighter than usual, so they drift instead of dropping straight through the column
• Mostly fished on 6X to give me natural movement
• My usual confidence patterns, just tied without the heavy beads
• A small box of unweighted or micro-weighted flies for the quietest water
• A few simple emergers in case I find subtle risers

I know I will have to change leaders during the day. I know I will have to shift from tight line presentations to floating the sighter if needed. I may even need to reach for an indicator when the depth or clarity demands it.

And there will be a lot of hunting.
More looking than casting.
More reading than reacting. This will change the way I see the river.

Watch Out for the Redds

I also know the redds will be visible. This is the beginning of the spawn. I will take note of where the bright gravel appears and remind myself to avoid those places in spring when the eggs and fry remain in the stones. I will give those places the space they deserve.

This is the time of year when the river needs attention. Even in its low state, the river and its inhabitants continue to perform their annual duties. I need to meet it with the same respect.

Looking Ahead

I have no idea how this trip will unfold.
Will my adjustments pay off, or will I revert to old habits? Will the lighter flies work, or will I doubt them the moment they touch the water? Will I have the discipline to stay patient?

I do not know. That is the point.

I have waited long enough for the river to return to what I think it should be. It is time to see it for what it is. I have a plan. The river has its own plan. Somewhere between the two, something meaningful will happen.

I will return next week with the rest of the story. I will tell you what I learned. I will let you know whether my assumptions hold up or whether the river reminds me once again that it does not answer to me.

Until then, I will pack the car, trust the preparation, and meet the river where it stands.

Part # 2 of a 3-Part Series: Go back to Part 1 or Part 3.

Stay Connected with TroutStrike.com

Follow TroutStrike.com on Instagram and Facebook @troutstrike for daily fly fishing tips, updates, and behind-the-scenes content.

Don’t forget to check out our YouTube channel for fly tying tutorials, nymphing techniques, and more. Subscribe and join the TroutStrike community today!

Thanks for reading! Spend more time on the water!

*Make sure to leave a comment below!

Have a great day!

Jeff Smecker